afoona
Stuffed Carp
fish

Stuffed Carp with homemade tomato paste

Carp stuffed with a mix of vegetables and spices in tomato sauce, a traditional festive dish

⏱ 5 hr 1 min🍽 4 servings 🌍 Israeli👩‍🍳 Afoona🧩 3 parts

👨‍🍳 Method

For the homemade tomato paste ✓ Homemade · or skip – back to store-bought

  1. 1
    Wash the tomatoes, remove the cores and quarter each tomato.
    KnifeCutting board
  2. 2
    Put the tomatoes, the salt and half of the olive oil in a wide pot, cover and cook over medium heat about 20 minutes, until the tomatoes soften and release their liquid.
    StoveWide, shallow pot
  3. 3
    Pass the tomatoes and their liquid through a food mill or sieve and return the purée to the pot: the skins and seeds stay behind.
    Food millorFine sieve
  4. 4
    Cook uncovered about an hour at a lively simmer, stirring now and then, until the purée reduces by half.
    StoveWooden spoon
    💡The paste burns easily as it dries: stir and scrape the bottom and edges, and once it is thick, don't walk away.
  5. 5
    Preheat the oven to 110°C (230°F).
    Oven
    💡Put things in the oven only once it's reached temperature, after the heating light has gone off: an oven that hasn't reached temperature changes baking times, and the bake burns outside or stays underbaked.
  6. 6
    Grease a wide baking dish with the rest of the olive oil and pour in the purée in a thin layer. Dry in the oven about 3 hours, stirring and scraping the edges every 30 minutes, until the paste is thick, sticky and brick red.
    OvenBaking sheetSilicone spatula
  7. 7
    Let the paste cool.
    Jar

For the Fish Stuffing

  1. 8
    Heat the olive oil in a pan over medium heat.
    StoveFrying pan
  2. 9
    Add the onion and carrot and fry, stirring, until they turn lightly golden.
    Stove
    💡Add by cooking time: what needs long (onion, carrot, meat) goes in first, and what burns fast (garlic, dry spices) goes in last, only until fragrant.
  3. 10
    Add the garlic and fry about 30 seconds to 1 minute, just until fragrant. Don't let the garlic brown.
    Stove
    💡Garlic burns quickly and turns bitter. Add it only after the onion has softened, over medium heat, and add the next ingredient as soon as it smells fragrant.
  4. 11
    Add the salt, black pepper and paprika and cook for another 2 minutes.
    Stove
  5. 12
    Transfer to a bowl, add the breadcrumbs and eggs and mix until combined.
    Bowl

To assemble

  1. 13
    Fill the fish with the mixture and sew up the belly with string.
    Kitchen twine
  2. 14
    Place the carp in a pot, add the tomato paste, water, olive oil, cumin and salt and cook over low heat for 40 minutes.
    StovePot
  3. 15
    Serve hot with the sauce and bread.
767calories
73 gprotein
19 gcarbs
42 gfat
● protein 39%● carbs 10%● fat 50%

Per serving, servings (calculated for this version)

A button hides that part of the recipe, in print too. Another click brings it back. The choice is kept for this recipe.

⚖ About the ingredients

🔧 Tools needed (4) · 🍳 2 cooking vessels

  • Stove · 💡 Workaround, changes the dish: Portable hot plate (one weaker burner) · Camping gas stove (One burner, outdoors) · Electric pressure cooker (multicooker) (One pot, no real shallow frying)
  • Frying pan · Also works: Wok (None) · 💡 Workaround, changes the dish: Pot (High sides, slow evaporation and weak browning)
  • Pot · Also works: Deep skillet (sauté pan) (less liquid, faster evaporation) · 💡 Workaround, changes the dish: Wok (For quick cooking)
  • Bowl · Also works: Pot (None)

🧻 Consumables: Kitchen twine

By the steps, as the recipe is built now: another version or addition can change the list.

🛒 Shopping list